Welcome to Romeo's Pizza Westerville
Located at 5733 Maxtown Rd in Westerville, OH, Romeo's Pizza Westerville has quickly garnered a loyal following for its delicious offerings and outstanding service. Renowned for its thin crust pizzas featuring old-world pepperoni and caramelized onions, patrons rave about the mouthwatering flavors and freshness. The veggie deluxe, densely packed with toppings, has also won accolades for its balanced sauce and quality. With quick delivery and attentive staff led by Melissa, dining experiences here feel personal and welcoming. Whether it's a family night in or a casual takeout, Romeo's is a delightful community staple that delivers on taste and hospitality.
Romeo's Pizza Westerville: Reviews & Ratings
Was just hand delivered one addicting pizza! We could not stop eating it. The thin crust with old world pepperoni and carmelized onion is the way to go! Fantastically made. Beyond delicious. Melissa and her team take excellent care of their customers with impeccable customer service. Very quick delivery and our driver was so kind. Melissa we appreciate you and your team and we thank you for being a part of the westerville community P.s. I didn't take a picture of the pizza because it was literally half gone by the time I got to this review
Fantastic Pizza!! Got the large veggie deluxe with traditional crust. Full of toppings. Sweet, but not overly sweet sauce. Picked it up it was hot and ready early. Andrea was helpful since this was our first visit. 18.49 for the large 14” pizza. Check for online order coupons when you pick it up. Easy parking in front of the store.
I usually don’t leave a review but this pizza was very good tonight, the crist was perfect and the sauce amount was amazing! Just look at it
My pizzas were hot, delicious, and very appealing! I will definitely order again!
Really scratching my head here why this place is not over 4 stars! Have ordered three times for delivery and each time it was great. First time ordering with my wife at home as she usually wants to get Jet's but talked her into Romeo's. My duaghter's loved it and so did my wife. The wings are hit or miss, but you get that with all pizza places, but the calzones are great! I have had two now and they are stuffed with ingrediants, not like Jet's deli boats where it is all bread! Hope to start making this a weekly family order. Note, they actually have their own drivers so not given to someone from Grubhub, Uber, etc. Great experience all around!
We LOVE Romeo’s Pizza!! Their pizza sauce is amazing! We drive 20 miles to pick up Romeo’s!! Great food, friendly and helpful service!! 10 stars!!
We have noticed this restaurant for so long but didn't try it because of the low rating. The first time we went, we got a large pizza and breadsticks. The order was finished on time, and had no issue with pickup. Surprisingly, their crust was so fluffy that we would not want to waste any of it. However, they didn't seal the sauce properly and left the portion cups upside down, which caused a mess. We returned and tried more flavors and traditional wings. The pizza quality was stable, but the wings differed slightly from what we expected. The wings' size was much larger than the average restaurant, which was good, but the skin was not crispy. You may try it if you are a meat lover but don't mind having non-crispy wings.
I ordered two pizzas from Romeos last week and ours was not good. There was about an inch of crust on the outside of the pizza and it was dry.I called and spoke with the manager and told him about my disappointment with the pizza. I was trying to remember why we ordered from this restaurant. The manager gave us a 20 dollar credit on our card so we thought we might as well use it. We ordered a large pizza again tonight and it was fabulous. I suddenly remembered why we like their pizzas. The sauce came out to the edge of the crust and the flavor was wonderful. Thank you Romeos for restoring my faith in complaining when it's not right.
Location
-
5733 Maxtown Rd, Westerville, OH 43082, United States Hotline: +1 614-895-5555
Welcome to the delightful world of Romeo's Pizza Westerville, a gem nestled on Maxtown Rd in Westerville, Ohio. With its commitment to crafting exceptional pizzas, Romeo's Pizza stands out as a cherished dining spot in the community. Offering a warm and inviting atmosphere, it’s no wonder patrons rave about their experiences here.
From the moment you step through the door or place your order online, you're greeted with unparalleled customer service. Customers like Jenna Kemp highlight the dedication of the staff, specifically praising Melissa and her team for their attentiveness and quick delivery. This kind of care enhances the overall dining experience and creates a sense of belonging in the Westerville community.
Now let’s talk about the pizza. The reviews speak volumes. Chuck Losch extols the virtues of the large veggie deluxe, which packs a punch with a perfect balance of toppings and sauce. The traditional crust received accolades for its flavor and texture. Meanwhile, Dan Vickers enthusiastically shares his family's newfound love for Romeo's, noting that their calzones are generously stuffed, unlike many competitors. Customers are pleasantly surprised to find that their pizzas arrive hot, ready, and with a freshness that can only come from quality ingredients.
Many have commented on the unique offerings at Romeo's. The thin crust pizza, particularly with the old-world pepperoni and caramelized onion, has gained a special place in the hearts of diners, creating an "addictive" experience, as Jenna noted. This speaks to the careful consideration that goes into the recipe and execution, resulting in a pizza that is not just a meal but an experience.
The cherry on top of this culinary cake is their convenient location, making it easy for locals to swing by for a delicious meal or a quick pickup. Additionally, patrons are encouraged to check out online coupons that make indulging in their favorite pizzas even more appealing.
In conclusion, if you find yourself in Westerville and craving authentic, flavor-packed pizza, look no further than Romeo's Pizza Westerville. This establishment is not just about good food; it's about community, care, and a commitment to excellence that keeps customers coming back for more. I, for one, can’t wait to return and explore more of their tantalizing menu!